Twenty-Ninth Sunday 'A'

Saturday October 15, 2005

Two Different Worlds

“Two different worlds, we live in, two different worlds, we love in….” These are the lyrics of a popular song dating back to ‘whenever.’ I don’t recall the year and I don’t remember all the words but the song came to mind as I reflected on the Scriptural selections for this weekend.

Actually we live not in two but in ten different worlds: the world of family, the world of work, school and play; the world of politics, the world of commerce and the money market; the world of the media; the world of science and the world of art. We have multiple memberships in many different worlds.

However, though different, they are not really distinct or truly separate. They overlap and at some level depend on and enrich one another. Who can truly appreciate the breadth and depth of the universe without music, e.g., New World Symphony or the Grand Canyon Suite? And there is nothing like Mahler’s Symphony number 2 – the Resurrection Symphony – to accompany a meditation on that core mystery of Christianity.

The Scriptures this weekend deal with two different worlds, which at first glance seem to be foundational texts for the ‘doctrine’ of the separation of church and state.

Our founding fathers made it clear that there would be no establishment of an official religious institution or favoritism shown to one over another but that religious freedom would be guaranteed to all. This was in response to the theocracies of ancient worlds in which one religion was cast in the role of ruler resulting in religious tyranny. The principle of the separation of church and state has been advantageous for both. The demise of religious practice in Europe is not just the result of secularism but also the result of excessive interference by religious leaders into the political sphere.

Confronted with the dissolution of the Papal States, the ‘fathers’ of the First Vatican Council in 1870 defined the Roman Catholic Church as a ‘juridically perfect society.’ It was a statement addressed more to secular rulers than to church members in order to make it clear that the Church of God was not to be hampered in the fulfillment of its mission to the world. On the other hand, the Church had usurped secular rule that resulted in the establishment of the Papal States in the first place. This definition also led to a kind of intolerance within the Church toward legitimate theological dissent evidenced in the discussion on birth control in the late sixties and in the present by papal prohibitions on the discussion of optional celibacy and the ordination of women.

The Second Vatican Council re-defined the Church as the ‘people of God’ clearly distinguishing its primary spiritual mission from its political role. However, although separate from government it is not detached or disinterested in the common good, public or political. It is an instrument of a spiritual liberation that also affects the common good. In fact, it can be and often is an agent for social change, the defender of the poor, champion of peace and the sacrament of God’s love for all people no matter the political state in which they reside. We do indeed whole a dual citizenship.

On the other hand, the state can hold religious institutions responsible for ethical behavior and public morality and accountable in the application of just laws.

Extremism at either end of the religious or political spectrum is tyranny and can only lead to the abuse of power and violence of one kind or another and the end does not justify the means. Our God is not a God of tyranny.

God used the pagan king Cyrus to free the Jewish people from the political extremism of his predecessor and from extremist tendencies even among the Jews themselves during their captivity in Babylon. In fact, Isaiah tells us in the first reading, that God “anointed” Cyrus that in effect made him a messianic figure and a prototype of the redeemer. Is this an outrageous assertion or what!

In Matthew’s account of the exchange between Jesus, the Herodians and Pharisees, the issue is not the separation of church and state but the superiority of God’s dominion over all—secular rulers as well as religious leaders. There is no goodness in this world without ‘Godness.’

It is our mission as a Christian church not to rule the world but to surrender to the dominion of God under the guidance of Jesus who is our true shepherd. This makes us not subservient to any secular or religious institution but responsible to God for the wellbeing of creation and its resources, responsible for the wellbeing of our neighbors near and far.

The great Oscar Romero, Archbishop of San Salvador and martyr put it this way in his final homily at Sunday Mass on March 24, 1980:

“Our hope for a new world must not deaden but increase our concern (and our efforts) to improve this world, where the new human family is taking shape and which will, in some way, be a dim pre-figuring of a new age. Although we must distinguish carefully between temporary progress and the growth of the kingdom of Christ, the former, nevertheless, has a lot to do with the latter in so far as it can contribute to improving society… May Jesus whose body was offered up and whose blood was shed for [humanity], give us that strength to offer ourselves in suffering and in sorrow, just as Jesus did not for himself but in order that the world might know true justice and peace.

“God’s reign is already present on our earth in mystery. When the Lord comes, it will it will be brought to perfection [This] is the hope that inspires Christians. We know that every effort to better society, especially when injustice and sin are so ingrained, is an effort that God blesses, that God wants, that God demands of us.”

Within minutes of that homiletic challenge, an assassin snuffed out Romero’s life but his voice will never be silenced.

“This [remains] our faith; this is the faith of our church. We are proud to profess it in Christ Jesus, our Lord.” [Response to Baptismal Promises, Baptismal Ritual]


Recent Articles

Seventh Sunday of Easter 'B'

Living the Mystery at the town square As I walked recently to the Green in the center of Morristown after my…continue reading...

Sixth Sunday of Easter 'C'

In all things, charity It continues to astound me how the Scriptures come to life over and over again under different…continue reading...

Sixth Sunday of Easter 'C'

In all things, charity It continues to astound me how the Scriptures come to life over and over again under different…continue reading...

Fifth Sunday of Easter 'B'

Let’s stay connected. It’s not unusual to hear family members or close friends at the departure gates of life say to…continue reading...

Fourth Sunday of Easter 'B'

Watch out for the leopards! When my sister and I were kids, my father would whistle for us when it was…continue reading...