Counting our Gains and Losses, Politically Speaking

Tuesday November 2, 2004

The hooting and shouting about winners and losers will soon give way to the paralysis of analysis and reform of the Democratic Party. Indicators are that there is also an agenda being prepared by the ‘old-time’ conservatives of the Republican Party who felt left out of recent discussions about party politics and American values. Stay tuned.

At this point it is not clear how influential was the so-called Catholic vote. What do you think? My bias tells me that it was not the Catholic vote that got Bush re-elected. I think Kerry did not make his case and so the old axiom that we learned in elementary school took over with the majority, “When in doubt, leave it out!” in other words, when there is doubt, the incumbent wins!

Whatever your political persuasion, the challenges remain greater than ever for both parties as it does for every American.

We’ve lost something over the past year or more and I believe it is the ‘virtue’ of civility. The debates were designed to titilate the ears of the electorate, i.e, to get votes rather than to inform. In my opinion, intelligent Americans abandoned hope of a true engagement of issues. I found them insulting—as insulting as the shallow commercials marketing candidates and selling votes. In fact, it was the commercial media who should also be held accountable because they reaped the benefits of no campaign finance reforms that neither party wanted to begin with. Billions of dollars for commercials and not one cent for true dialogue! Ugh.

Kerry had plans that were never elucidated. Bush has plans that are not working. Where do we go from here!

Our Catholic bishops pulled out all their stops, stopping just short of naming the candidates for whom we must ‘morally’ cast our ballots. Although many of their candidates may have won, I think in the long term, the bishops lost. Their credibility is not exactly at an all-time high.

Our bishop speaks about truth and logic in his weekly column but these ‘virtues’ have not been applied across the board to his brother bishops and to his own associates on the issue of accountability for the mishandling of sexual abuse to name only one issue.

It is my considered opinion that American Catholics need to get as serious about Church reform as they are about government reform but reform does not begin with shouts from the gallery but with the action of the mind and heart. As I stated in my last talk to Voice of the Faithful in Union County:

“Now comes the hard part. Don’t be alarmed but I believe most Catholics do not want reform any more than any one of us wants to reform our lives. It’s too hard to grow, to get well and to stay well spiritually. As a priest I engage in what I call pastoral transitional counseling. I enable people in trouble to get to the next step. Most hem and haw. It’s too much trouble to do the right thing.

With regard to Church reform, Catholics who are reasonably happy with their experience of parish are reluctant to protest or call for change. Moreover, those who are unhappy no longer practice. Some of us in the ‘middle’ are content to get our sacraments and get back to the routine of getting through the daily routine. These have been called the “hatched” (baptized), “matched” (married) and “dispatched” (buried) Catholics who do not have a high degree of ownership of their faith.

We want our monsignors to wear their purple and the bishops to don their mitres, and the Knights of Columbus to wear their plumes. Others are simply tired of the noise. Young people have resolved faith practice on their own terms.

Reform of the Church must begin with the reform of our lives under the direction of the Holy Spirit. The Bible is our source document. Vatican II one of many constitutional documents. The Beatitudes are the criteria; the gifts and fruits of the Holy Spirit are the barometer of true reform,

We are in this together, lay and ordained, pastors and people in the pew. We are not going back to the old way but we must accept the challenge to move on to a new order that reflects the mystery of God’s incarnate life in the Church, the Body of Christ.”

Father Lasch
kel@fatherlasch.com


Recent Articles

Seventh Sunday of Easter 'B'

Living the Mystery at the town square As I walked recently to the Green in the center of Morristown after my…continue reading...

Sixth Sunday of Easter 'C'

In all things, charity It continues to astound me how the Scriptures come to life over and over again under different…continue reading...

Sixth Sunday of Easter 'C'

In all things, charity It continues to astound me how the Scriptures come to life over and over again under different…continue reading...

Fifth Sunday of Easter 'B'

Let’s stay connected. It’s not unusual to hear family members or close friends at the departure gates of life say to…continue reading...

Fourth Sunday of Easter 'B'

Watch out for the leopards! When my sister and I were kids, my father would whistle for us when it was…continue reading...